Magazine / Trips & travel

Foraging for mushrooms: why it is better with two than alone

Marcel, founder of Sponties
Marcel Created on 1 October 2026 · 6 min read
Forest path between tall trees in the sunlight

In October the forest is fuller than in any other month. And hardly any leisure activity is so geared towards not doing it alone: if you are starting out, you need someone who already knows what they are holding in their hand.

The month when the forest is full

Mushrooms need two things: moisture and soil that is still warm. October delivers exactly this combination — the summer has heated the soil, the autumn rain brings the water. One to two weeks after a proper spell of steady rain is the best time, and it lasts until the first hard frost. That makes the month the natural window to start: if you find nothing in October, it isn’t bad luck, you were in the wrong place.

What you may pick — and where not at all

The rule is personal use. In most forests you may pick mushrooms for your own basket, but not to sell, and in nature reserves and national parks a complete ban generally applies. Several federal states give one to two kilograms per person per day as a guideline, but the details are state law and differ. Then there is the landowner’s right: private forest stays private forest, and a sign on the path is binding. If you check this beforehand rather than afterwards, you can enjoy your day.

Why an app doesn’t replace the expert

Identification apps have got good, but they give probabilities, not certainty. The death cap, responsible for most fatal mushroom poisonings in Germany, looks similar enough to young button mushrooms and some brittlegills that a photo from above decides nothing. What matters isn’t shown in a picture: the bulb in the ground, the ring on the stem, the smell, the colour of the cut. That is why the hard rule every forager knows applies — whatever you can’t identify with certainty doesn’t go in the basket and certainly not in the pan.

Mushroom experts, guided walks, clubs

For exactly this gap there is an infrastructure that hardly anyone knows about. The German Mycological Society (Deutsche Gesellschaft für Mykologie) keeps a directory of certified mushroom experts who look at finds and assess them — free of charge in many cities. Adult education centres, NABU groups and local mushroom clubs offer guided walks in autumn, and that is the fastest route from zero to a handful of species you recognise. That such courses start in autumn applies not only to mushrooms: see Courses from autumn.

Why two is worth more than double

When foraging, a second pair of eyes helps twice over: you find more, and you find it more safely, because two assessments are better than one. Then there is the side effect that this is really about. Three hours in the forest are three hours of conversation with no table in between, with constant natural pauses and something to do with your hands. For people who find small talk tiring, that is a better format than any café — more in Doing things together instead of small talk.

The kit is short

A breathable basket, no plastic bag — in one, mushrooms turn mushy within hours. A knife for cutting instead of pulling, sturdy shoes, long trousers, a charged phone. Plus a tick check in the evening, because they are still active in October. All of it together costs less than a night at the cinema, and the basket lasts decades.

What comes after the basket

Prepare mushrooms on the day you find them, cook them thoroughly and don’t store them for long. Keep different species separate — if one later turns out to be wrong, the whole basket isn’t affected. And in case anyone feels unwell after eating: keep leftovers and trimmings and call the poison emergency line straight away. The numbers of the poison information centres are staffed around the clock, and the leftovers are the only way to clarify what was actually in the pot.

Frequently asked questions

When is the best time for foraging mushrooms?
How many mushrooms can you pick?
Can I identify mushrooms with an app?
Where do I find someone who knows what they are doing?
What should I do if I suspect mushroom poisoning?

Find someone to come along

On Sponties you can set up a mushroom walk or join one — free, ad-free and without using your real name.

Join for free